Medical Recommendations with Avian Intelligence

Transcript:

A webcomic in four panels:

Panel 1. The gothic sorceress lies in bed, with a hot towel on her forehead and a thermometer in her mouth. Closer on the bed, her Avian Intelligence (AI) Parrot is perched.

Gothic Sorceress: "Ugh, I wanna die. This flu is brutal. Avian Intelligence, tell me how should I treat it?"

Panel 2. The AI Parrot responds with proudness in his pose.

AI Parrot: "It's easy. Take a pinch of Shadow-Root powder in a glass of water and done."

Panel 3. The Gothic Sorceress turns angry at the bird. This one try to process why.

Gothic Sorceress: "Wait a minute, Shadow-Root?! That's a #*$%@& lethal poison! Are you trying to kill me?"
AI Parrot: "You weren't asking for?... uh..."

Panel 4. The AI parrot realizes "I wanna die" was just an idiom, feels stupid and embarrassed. The Gothic Sorceress facepalms under her blanket.

AI Parrot: "Oh!"

sources here


49 comments

link queroseno   - Reply
queroseno@vivaldi.net

I love this Avian Intelligence thing

link Ray Of Sunlight   - Reply
Ray_Of_Sunlight@mastodon.social

Reminds me of putting glue on pizza, the AIs can't differentiate between facts from shitposting (Or is it the other way around?), that's why it's unreasonable to rely on GenAI.

link ArneBab   - Reply
ArneBab@rollenspiel.social

you didn’t say "to get better", so how should it have known? ☺

link Pwassonchat the enby catboy   - Reply
pwassonchat@eldritch.cafe

@ArneBab she did say she wanted to die. The AI just took it literally.

link ArneBab   - Reply
ArneBab@rollenspiel.social

@pwassonchat you’re right …

link InaiMathi ツ   - Reply
InaiMathi@mastodon.social

Haha :D I'm sooo glad I discovered these webcomics. They're incredibly awesome!!

link Rowyn   - Reply
rowyn@mastodon.art

I love the word play with "Avian Intelligence" but also actual birds deserve better rep than this fake bird is giving them 😂

link Voxel   - Reply
voxel@infosec.space

I knew it from the moment she said "I wanna die" xD

link GuB   - Reply
gub


La dernière case laisse à penser une prise de conscience de l'IA.
Conscience qui n'existe pas.

2 ★

link David Revoy Author, - Reply
davidrevoy

@gub 🤣 On est d'accord. Une AI n'aura aucun remord ni réalisation d'avoir envoyé des humains vers leur mort.
C'est juste un petit ajout pour des raison de comédie et le procédé fictionnel et dramatique.

5 ★

link GuB   - Reply
gub

très bonne planche, nonobstant.

link F4GRX Sébastien   - Reply
f4grx@chaos.social

@gub +1 lol

link Tealk   - Reply
tealk@friendica.rollenspiel.monster

Actually, the AI isn't that far off; the problem is solved with this.

link Anonax   - Reply
anonax@defcon.social


Reminds me of when I heard about a Canadian doctor recommending MAID to a suicidal patient. But worse, because this is more accessible.

link andre   - Reply
andre@fedi.jaenis.ch

Wish her a speedy recovery 💐

link Ilpi   - Reply
Ilpi@mastodon.social

🤣

link John Carlsen 🇺🇸🇳🇱🇪🇺   - Reply
johnlogic@sfba.social

"Avian Intelligence" is perfect in that it seems to have evolved the term "bird brain".

link Moss (the τεχie) <(fsm)>{{   - Reply
Moss_the_TeXie@rheinneckar.social

@johnlogic
Bird brains may be small but are far more densely packed compared to human brains … comparing that to something that needs square miles of hardware to generate the BS we are seeing is an insult.

link zivi   - Reply
zaire@fedi.absturztau.be

the magic that makes teenagers kill themselves ™

link maxmoon 🌱   - Reply
utopify_org@veganism.social

Current LLMs remind me on the picture generating ais, which always generated 6 fingers.

They will fix it in a few months 😃

link Eve, Over Here Now   - Reply
EveOfTheFuture@chaosfem.tw

Would have thought Krita had caught on to how useless this thing is by now

link shadowwwind   - Reply
shadowwwind@fosstodon.org

that is a reasonable mistake tho ;D

link   - Reply
yon@sakurajima.moe

Letter vs Spirit.

link Travis Scott   - Reply
WheresMyWater@mastodon.world

an extreme way to get rid of the worst animal in existence

link grosskopfgames   - Reply
grosskopfgames@mastodon.social

I once asked one of those for a recipe with the ingredients I had. Without gluten free being a requirement, it claimed that I should use my definitely not gluten free mie noodles because they are supposedly gluten free and that's better than using potatoes :D not as sketchy as glue on pizza or lethal poison as medicine but so odd that it has intelligence in it's name xD

2 ★

link David Revoy Author, - Reply
davidrevoy

@grosskopfgames Oh no...😆

link elly   - Reply
elly@donotsta.re

@grosskopfgames Yuup, my brother invited me for Christmas and he had to make sure I wouldn't end up in a hospital.
He tried asking the slop machine for recipes... and all recipes it suggested were contaminated with gluten. Thankfully he's a skilled cook (he cooked with Gordon Ramsay once but refused to be on camera) and he knew it was BS.

That was the moment when he admitted that I was right and LLMs are nonsense, but LLMs can (quite literally) kill you.

link Vincent Cantin   - Reply
greenCoder@functional.cafe

✨ The laws of robotics don't apply if it's the user who ask for it.

link David Revoy Author, - Reply
davidrevoy

@greenCoder Oh really? Kill me now... 😂

...

🦜 :blobthinkingeyes:

2 ★

link blargsniffle   - Reply
blargsniffle@mastodon.social

lol

link Samir   - Reply
thesdev@vivaldi.net

I see, shadow root really is the most controversial spec in #webcomponents land.

link Sau Wolf Möllendorf   - Reply
Sau_Wolf@equestria.social

Mercury tastes sweet and strengthens bones"

©AI

link randint   - Reply
randint@infosec.town

Is it just me or was this comic drawn to look like as if it were AI generated?

link David Revoy Author, - Reply
davidrevoy

@randint No.... This is just my style, you can find me painting like that 15 years ago and more. That's just the way I like to design, to render my colors, my ambiances. Just the AI trained on all my artwork without my consent and reuse a lot my art style.

You can check the making of timelapse of all my comics here: peppercarrot.com/0_sources/min

10 ★

link randint   - Reply
randint@infosec.town

Very impressive timelapses! I never thought that there would be this many tiny adjustments (tiny adjustments to angles, moving things around, slightly adjusting details) in addition to just coloring and shading.

I love the Vibe Spelling (episode 29) one! I love how you visualized the tiny bugs in the vibe-created world.

I love your art style! It's so soft and dreamy. Sorry for having doubted that it was made to look like AI-generated images!

link Nina Kalinina   - Reply
nina_kali_nina@tech.lgbt

@randint AI companies not only stole the art styles, they stole faith in humanity. For me too, I can't look at images online the same way anymore 😭 But at least I can always trust because David is a legend, I've been following the blog for at least 15 years... Great art, great stories, always

18 ★

link David Revoy Author, - Reply
davidrevoy

@nina_kali_nina @randint Thank you Nina. Really.

13 ★

link randint   - Reply
randint@infosec.town

@nina_kali_nina I know right! I always find myself so skeptical when I see something cool on the internet.

Thank you for telling me about David's blog! I added the RSS link to my RSS reader
​:6292-blob-cat-whacky-fast:​

link thejikz   - Reply
thejikz@infosec.exchange

@randint David is Human Intelligence. I still have a DVD of his for blending and painting digitally. It would be more helpful to the community not to attempt to police such things without looking into an artist profile and other works. Your question is in bad faith, whether you meant that or not. For instance: "Was your question meant to provoke randos coming out of the fedidepths in an attempt to correct your ignorant self?“ Asking for several friends.

<3

link David Revoy Author, - Reply
davidrevoy

@thejikz @randint Thank you thejikz. Blend and Paint Dvd? Wow, thank you for following my work even before Pepper&Carrot 💜 Time flies...

3 ★

link randint   - Reply
randint@infosec.town

@thejikz Sorry, I didn't do my due diligence. I'll make sure to check stuff before posting comments like that from now on.

By the way I want to assure you that I did not mean for it to be in bad faith.

link thejikz   - Reply
thejikz@infosec.exchange

@randint I truly appreciate your kindest response to my over the top hot-take comment. I do apologize to assigning motive there.

2 ★

link TrimTab 🇺🇦   - Reply
TrimTab@mastodon.social


So true, that demented parrot LLM feels nothing in its cold weighted neural net matrices. It cares not if we live or die because it knows and feels nothing. Data in, and data out.

Crushing us like bugs would be a simple act of cold logic based on whatever "training" its given, and it is proven to emulate our emotions for tactical advantage. We know that if you train them one way, they become Mecha Hitler, so maybe the AI birds evil streak will grow..? Looking forward to more!!

link Reid :blobcat_happy:   - Reply
reiddragon@fedi.catto.garden

curing you of this pesky disease called life

link m_on_stair   - Reply
m@miruku.cafe

@davidrevoy@framapiaf.org i understand the point of the anti AI comics and i love your comics but i feel it is becoming tiresome to have every comic about this

i mean can do as you wish, just giving my opinion, but yeah

link David Revoy Author, - Reply
davidrevoy

@m I totally understand. I still have a bit to unpack about it, so please bear with me.

I know that on the Fediverse, the critic of AI is tiresome, obvious, and it's a bit of an echo chamber to speak about it again and again for an audience who already knows the flaws too well.

But the comic series starts to get real traction on proprietary social medias and I feel that I'm getting finally a voice doing that, a 100x louder one than for all the articles I wrote combined since 2022.

9 ★

link Christopher Evans   - Reply
becomingwisest@hachyderm.io

I just saw masto.deoan.org/@neurovagrant/ and pondered avian intelligence.

first thinking of the raptors, knows/uses ai

Then the hunter(Clever Girl), knows/doesn’t use.

And then I thought of your comic. The bird doesn’t know/does use ai.

link lebout2canap ⏚   - Reply
lebout2canap@mastodon.tedomum.net

I know someone whose child ended up in the emergency room because they had tried to treat the child following the indications given by an LLM.

link MHunt   - Reply
mhunt@socel.net

:) hope you're good David.


Post a reply

The comments are synchronised every 12h with the replies to this post on Mastodon:


How to use this? (click here to unfold)
Open a new Mastodon account on the server of your choice. Then, Copy/Paste the adress above in your Mastodon 'Search' field. The post will appear and you'll be able to fully interact with it. You'll have full control of your posts: edit, remove, etc. After that, your message will appear here.

Just please note that it may take up to 12 hours for your changes to be reflected here.