Security

Transcript:

A comic in four panels.

Panel 1. A sorcerer is standing in front of the closed main gate of a tall and dark castle. The guard, on the wall of the castle, shouts:

Guard: Halt, stranger! Do you have the password?
Sorcerer: Yes, it's DarkLord123!

Panel 2. Zoom on the guard, shouting another test:

Guard: What about the security code sent to your address?
Sorcerer: Oh yes, I have that: 75482.

Panel 3. The guard now hangs a big poster, absurd: there is on it a picture of a horse on a landscape, but it is split into many squares. The laser wand of the sorcerer selects all the squares with horses.

Guard: Now, use your magic to show me all the squares with horses. Good.

Panel 4. Shot of the sorcerer, visibly very bored by all these tests, opening his mouth.

Guard (off-panel): Finally, prove that you're an adult by closing and opening your mouth.
Sorcerer: Really?...

This comic strip is a critique of the too many security steps in 2025: login/password, 2FA security code, captchas, and adult verification via webcam expression.

Source here



License: "Security" by David Revoy − CC-BY-SA 4.0
Tags:  #webcomic  #minifantasytheater   | Download: Markdown
37 comments

37 comments

link Tealk   - Reply
Tealk@rollenspiel.social

on a scale of 1 to 10, how pleased will my players be if I incorporate something like this?

link Tuchowski   - Reply
adipoeserPursch@troet.cafe

@Tealk 😜😂😂

link Arioch   - Reply
Arioch

@Tealk -7

link Sir Toootenstein   - Reply
sir_toootenstein@det.social

@Tealk 0.1 😂

link Marco Bresciani   - Reply
AAMfP@fosstodon.org

@Tealk
42

link Albert Westra   - Reply
odysseywestra@linuxrocks.online

Yup this is getting ridiculous...

📎 original 

link Beko Pharm   - Reply
bekopharm@indieweb.social

@odysseywestra it does.

What to do though? This is from an old forum of mine that is crawled into oblivion 24/7 with severe rate limits and block lists already in place:

> Currently active users: 7451 [1 Member(s), 7444 Guest(s) and 6 Spider(s)]

Add Anubis? That'll kill legit search engines too.

Kill the forum? Sad for the collected knowledge of 2 decades. Granted, niche topic but still.

I'm at a loss and I hate this timeline.

link Feyter   - Reply
feyter@mastodon.gamedev.place

this will change very soon. For proofing you are an adult you will have to provide your complete identity with postal address and medical history... at least if some politicians have their way.

link Lagz | Comms open!   - Reply
lagz@mastodon.social

@feyter oh god. Next up - biometrics

link Voxel   - Reply
voxel@infosec.space

@feyter Don't forget the birth certificate!

link Glenn Seto   - Reply
glennseto@mastodon.social

But I hear this castle has the best Roman folios featuring naturalistic depictions of nudity. ☝️

link 𝓬𝓪𝓷𝓪𝓻𝔂 🏳️‍⚧️🦋🌱   - Reply
dianea@lgbtqia.space

"And select all the 220 ohm resistors"

link Ygor   - Reply
ygor@floss.social

Then he walks in and hundreds of cookies fall on his head.

link Voxel   - Reply
voxel@infosec.space

Passkeys ✨

link 𝙎𝙩𝙤𝙢𝙖𝙩𝙖 🥼🧫   - Reply
Stomata@social.linux.pizza

and you got blocked by cloudflare 😬

link Momo   - Reply
momo@social.linux.pizza


This reminds me of this particular meme.

And yes, I'm fully aware, that machine learning tools can nowadays pass capcha tests faster and more successful than humans, making all those tests obsolete...

🖼️ 5e6ebbafbe8d8654.jpg 

link LarsNygard   - Reply
Lach@social.linux.pizza

@momo but can they solve the captchas slow and make lots of mistakes like humans? Never ...

link Momo   - Reply
momo@social.linux.pizza

@Lach
Tell the ML to select the fields with a score of 85-90 as well and create a delay between the clicks of a random interval between 100 and 250ms to simulate human input. That's super easy.

link LarsNygard   - Reply
Lach@social.linux.pizza

@momo The AI will never scream at the screen like a human. It will just answer the next captcha with a "You're right, that wasn't a trafic light. sorry for my mistake, here is the correct reply" and make some more errors.

Only when the LLMs learns to throw laptops out of the window in anger, will they truly be able to replicate human behaviour.
🤪

link Elf Burgerman   - Reply
elfburgerman@mastodon.social


Not one of the squares has horses. Not even all the squares together have horses. I hate those tests asking me for a plural with only pictures of a (partial) singular! If you want to communicate with me, do what's decent: stick to the consensus!

link Cy   - Reply
cy@fedicy.us.to

None of the squares have a single horse, either. Nine of the squares do, but each one of the 9 only has part of a horse.

CC: @davidrevoy@framapiaf.org

link Cryptic   - Reply
eclypia@app.wafrn.net

Ugh yeah

link Florian   - Reply
Nefex@ruhr.social

Very funny one, thank you.

link Mr. Bruno :antiverified:   - Reply
mrbruno@mstdn.social

I remember the days when you only needed to know some avian trivia.

link Aljoša   - Reply
avart@mastodon.art

four-step authentication 😀

link Stefan   - Reply
kranzkrone@quasselkopf.de


Thank you for sharing this and also providing another great draft for printing on a t-shirt. 😁🤩👍

MADE MY DAY!‼️🤟
@citizenk4te

#webcomic #krita #miniFantasyTheater

link Rémi Dupré   - Reply
remidupre@mas.to

awesome, as usual
! ❤️

This also reminds me of this old comic (godamn I miss commitstrip so much 😢)

commitstrip.com/en/2012/06/29/

🖼️ 27a7bd97dd968737.jpg 

link Alex   - Reply
xinayder@fosstodon.org

meanwhile, when a robot has this information, it passes the captcha automatically

link Adam   - Reply
adamsdesk@fosstodon.org

I love it, thank you for a good laugh. 😆

link Jigme Datse   - Reply
JigmeDatse@social.openpsychology.net

@davidrevoy@framapiaf.org "I just wanted your recipe for pico de gallo, maybe I'll find it somewhere else."

link Jer Clarke   - Reply
jerclarke@mastodon.social

Love your art, beautiful stuff, thanks for sharing ❤️‍🔥

link Vincent Cantin   - Reply
greenCoder@functional.cafe

That's the modern version of "I fart in your general direction" by Monty Python.

🖼️ b9aa9edf89819ca9.png 

link Jean-Paul Lepine   - Reply
LepineJPaul@mastodon.social

: Superb comic book, but does it exist in French?

link David Revoy Author, - Reply
davidrevoy

@LepineJPaul Merci! Alors oui grâce au travail de @Nartance qui traduit les épisodes bénévolement (encore merci!), c'est sur le site → peppercarrot.com/fr/miniFantas

link Nartance Contributor - Author of Pepper&Carrot Mini - French translation, - Reply
Nartance

@LepineJPaul 😁👌🥰

link Jean-Paul Lepine   - Reply
LepineJPaul@mastodon.social

@Nartance : Merci beaucoup pour votre réactivité ! J'utiliserai certainement !

2 ★

link   - Reply
coffin_rock@eatzeri.ch

this is so funny ! because it's unfortunately true !


Post a reply

The comments are synchronised every 12h with the replies to this post on Mastodon:


How to use this? (click here to unfold)
Open a new Mastodon account on the server of your choice. Then, Copy/Paste the adress above in your Mastodon 'Search' field. The post will appear and you'll be able to fully interact with it. You'll have full control of your posts: edit, remove, etc. After that, your message will appear here.

Just please note that it may take up to 12 hours for your changes to be reflected here.